I think that Auradon would make pirates be seen as evil, especially after the whole Captain Hook situation.
But if being a pirate is generalized as an ‘evil thing’, does that mean the rest of the pirates of Neverland could be sent to the Isle as well? I don’t doubt that people like Captain Jake and Red Jessica would be exempt, but what about ones like Captain Beatrice Le Beak? There are several pirate crews and even more pirates that sail across the Never Sea.
If being a pirate is a crime in Auradon’s messed-up system, then alongside the petty thieves, there should be many pirates as well on the Isle of the Lost.
Only the heavens know how many excuses the Beast (huh, that nickname seems the most fitting now more than ever) would look for just to throw someone inside that island prison.
Neverland already hates Auradon’s guts enough for attempting to conform them to their system.
Would love to hear your guys’ thoughts on this! (Sorry for any grammar mistakes.)